This week Signal Instant Message Establishment Gains close attention. The reason is the senior officials of the Donald Trump administration They added a journalist in a journalist in the hidden chat room of the stageIt was used to discuss the immediate US military action against Yemen’s Hoodis. The journalist says that you can read all the details of the attack plans They were written in that group.
The Prasida de Signal, Meridith VittakerHe did not directly approach the controversy but he has raised his voice Protect the safety of the message. He has done it, yes, secured in another debate: like In response to your opponent’s previous statements on WhatsApp, the Cadgart bowHe recently said that there were no major differences between the two sites.
“Will and I won’t say that I fought, but I have not agreed. Why There are great differences between the signal and WhatsAppVittaker wrote on X (Twitter) and described its site “Gold quality in private communications” Metadata and protect messages”, He added.
Vittcher calls users to access the part of their website called ‘Big Brother’ Check the “some data” that collects the site.
In his message, in addition, Vittaker points out, unlike the signal WhatsApp – Meta prototype – does not protect the secret metadata Like the list of contacts, with whom he communicates, the time of the messages or the profile photo. “When they are forced, like all the companies that collect data, They offer this important and revealing data“, Remember.
Although he admits it He “loves” the use of the technology of WhatsApp signal —It Use It uses the same intensity to end the encryption protocol (E2E) as a signal for the news from the target – criticizing the safety metadata or the business version.
And emphasizes: ”They are the main differences in the case of significant privacy, and the public are eligible to understand them”.
Controversy between the signal and WhatsApp
In the recent interview Dutch newspaper D Telegraph He had access to Cyber newsVittcher criticized data collection procedures WhatsApp And said that the message was application Collects many secret metadataSignal’s leader describes the words of the Signal’s former director as “death.”“We kill people based on metadata”He quotes in the interview).
Metadata, continues, ”They tell you who you are in contact with, at what time, how many times, and where they are. From that you can get a lot of information. WhatsApp can Connect that information to Facebook, Instagram And the payment data they can buy. The signal is simply not all that data, ”he said.
Vittcher’s reports are not overlooked. Will Gadcart responded During a meeting with journalists in the Netherlands last week, there He denied that WhatsApp collects such information. “We firmly believe in private communications,” he said. “WhatsApp does not record who is not shared with other companies who or when location data and contact information.”
A WhatsApp spokesman promised it The Use Use some metadata to avoid Spam And abuseIt does not monitor personal messages or uses them for advertising purposes.
Signal users grow up
Acute privacy policy is one of the factors behind the increase in the popularity of the signal, along with its non -profit model.
According to Tower sensor data Collector ReoidOvarian Signal downloads in the United States have increased by 16% in the quarter since 2025 As for the previous quarter, 25%compared to the same 2024 period.
Sign up with us Newsletter Get the latest messages about technology in your mail.
